ROMANTICISM - A CONTRADICTION IN TERMS?

 

Romanticism in the eighteen hundreds A.D., dealt with subjects that were dramatic, sentimental and nostalgic. (205) "It represented vindication of the individual and his changeable personality, of sensitivity, emotion and inner values." (206) Romantic artists and writers often escaped from reality into the world of dreams, the imagination, and the mythical past. (207) This fits with our notion of `romantic', fairly easily.
 

The content however, was often disturbing, with " a taste for the mysterious, the appalling, the sinister or the
bloodthirsty" (208). This fits less with what I would call romantic, but would explain a group of painters today who refer to themselves as the `young romantics'.


Webster's definition of romanticism does include "a predilection for melancholy" along with "an emphasis on emotions", (209) which would have to accept the ominous, the evil, and the injurious. I will have to redefine my own idea of romanticism. Previously it had only incorporated the idealistic, quixotic, and the heroic.

 



"... today in both psychology and the arts there is danger of confusing the elementary with the profound. Cultures in their late, refined stages seem to develop a weakness for primitivism, and one of the forms this inclination takes in our own case is the temptation to believe that the areas of the mind farthest away from consciousness harbour the deepest wisdom. This belief strikes me as a romantic superstition." (210)
Rudolf Arnheim


 


"... before an artist decides passively to surrender to the spontaneous impulses coming to him from below the threshold, he may wish to remember that such utterances tend to be chaotic. This is known from dreams, which are entangled compounds of many disparate mental processes; it is known from the doodles we produce when our attention is blocked or absorbed elsewhere; or from the automatic writings of the Surrealists." (211)
Rudolf Arnheim




"... the oracle, uttered in a state of possession, speaks with inarticulate tongues that need interpretation. The prophet, on the other hand, does not befog his mind with Delphic fumes, the jungle drugs of savages, or strong drink. His method of getting away from `himself' is not that of distraction but profound concentration, which requires severe discipline of all mental powers and gives shape and depth to his pronouncements." (212)
Rudolf Arnheim



205. Gina Pischel, A World History of Art, (New York, Golden Press, 1968), p. 588
206. ibid., p. 582
207. ibid., p. 588
208. ibid., p. 584
209. A Merriam-Webster, ed. H. B. Woolf, Webster's New Collegiate Dictionary (Springfield, Mass., U.S.A., G & C. Merriam Co.,1976),p. 1004
210. Rudolf Arnheim, Toward a Psychology of Art, (Berkeley and L.A., Cal., University of California Press, 1966), p. 289
211. ibid., p. 289
212. ibid., p. 290

 

Home | Up

Topics

1.00 Preface
1.01 From Idol to Icon and So On
2.00 What is Art?
2.01 Good Art
2.02 The Artist as Child
2.03 Matisse and Picasso
2.04 The Need for Drawing
2.05 The Need to Teach Children to Draw
2.06 Geometrical Figures are the Essence of Drawing
2.07 Misunderstanding of Form
2.08 Pebbles Show Nature's Way
2.09 People Love Abstractions
2.10 Our Faults
2.11 Technical Skill
2.12 Quality and Time on Painting
2.13 Originality and Creative Courage
2.14 Respect for the Successful Innovator
2.15 Bizarre Stuff
2.16 A Great Artist
2.17 Get Yourself a Gimmick
2.18 Unceasing Change
2.19 Blue Period
2.20 Cheap Repetition
3.00 The Artist
3.01 Understanding
3.02 Solitude
3.03 Full Circle
3.04 Myth Making
3.05 A Taste for a Few and Simple Things
3.06 There is Such a Thing as Talent
3.07 The Ouija Board
3.08 Artists and Other Circus Acts
3.09 We Don't Need Another Hero
3.10 The Van Gogh Syndrome
3.11 A State of Being
3.12 The Dreaded Dry Spell
3.13 Art is no Occupation For Relaxed People
3.14 Illustrator or Artist?
3.15 Good Versus Evil
3.16 We Belong to Our Time
3.17 The Artist of the Surface
3.18 Where Have all the Artist's Gone
3.19 Everywhere Artists are Painting Flowers
4.00 The Art
4.01 No Content No Form
4.02 Selecting the Subject
4.03 The Real World has Much to Offer
4.04 Beautiful Bird or Piece of Paper
4.05 Time
4.06 Art is a Reflection on Society
4.07 A Note on the Subtlety in Painting
4.08 Ugly Art
4.09 Decoration or Art?
4.10 The Pendulum Swings
4.11 Cartoons an Art Form
4.12 Sculpture Arises out of Garbage
4.13 Real Visual Discovery
4.14 Technology and Art
4.15 Discoveries and Art
4.16 Something Wrong with Technology
4.17 Skyscraperism
4.18 Art Suits the Purpose
4.19 The Monotony ofthe Mechanical
4.20 Firstest is Almost Always Mostest
4.21 Anything Goes
4.22 Seeing Something Worthwhile
4.23 Big Government Involvement in Art
4.24 Art for Art's Sake
4.25 Out Like Seal Skin Boots
4.26 An Idea of Aestheticism
4.27 Art as Entertainment
4.28 I Love Good Movies
4.29 Van Gogh Museum
4.30 Visual Pollution
4.31 On Architecture and Painted Murals
5.00 Art in Terms of Yesterday
5.01 On Abstract Art
5.02 Abstract, Avant Garde
5.03 Abstract Realism
5.04 Minimalism or Minimal Art
5.05 Old Ways Coming Through Again
5.06 The Minor Arts
5.07 A Frightening Insight into Realism
5.08 Historical Values
5.09 Art for the Aristocracy
5.10 A Democratic Art
5.11 The Growth of Bourgeoisie and Art
5.12 Art and Religion
5.13 A Note on Chinese Painting
5.14 Romanticism a Contradiction in Terms?
6.00 Qualities and Art
6.01 Paucity in Art
6.02 The Vital Brushmark
6.03 Every Idea has its own Size
6.04 Nature Has Taught Us
6.05 Interior Design School
6.06 Nature Teaches us about Patterns
6.07 Nature Teaches us about Lines
6.08 Nature Teaches us about Textures
6.09 Our Senses Get Dulled
6.10 Symbols may be General or Specific
6.11 Old Friends
7.00 Feelings in Art Today
7.01 A Growing Indifference to Art
7.02 The Big Show
7.03 Lifestyle Dictates Taste
7.04 Art is Most Enjoyed
7.05 Infatuation and Art
7.06 Enjoy Children's Art
7.07 Something to Match the Sofa
7.08 For the Joy or the Pain
7.09 Freedom, Money, and Artist's Expectations
7.10 Icons the Public
7.11 Confusion About Prints
7.11 Confusion About Prints
7.12 The Big Business of Art
7.13 Beware of the Retailer Dealer
7.14 Rarity
7.15 The Wealthy and the Arts
7.16 Every Tiny Scratch
7.17 The Thin Wolf
7.18 Even Artists Underestimate Art
7.19 Intuition and the Senses
8.00 In Search of Truth
8.01 Come into my Closet
8.02 Freedom
9.00 In Conclusion

 

 

 

    Copyright: Sharon Christian, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada